(no subject)

[aedifica]

Thank you, Hydra! (So, in our world, thank you Hydra's player and Tosha's player.) Your post about what you saw when you legilimised Dolohov* answers a lot of questions for me--especially the question of what Selwyn's request to him was.

* Apparently I can't call him one thing, either!

Comments

[aedifica]

Have you seen Draco's response to Justin's wallotext? I'm really enjoying that conversation now, and what it shows about both of them.

[batrachian]

Just read it. I'm still far more firmly on Justin's side than Draco's, and while I can see the point Draco is trying to make, the tone and language he's using is extremely accusatory and insulting, and that gets my hackles up regardless of any actual content.

is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[sporky_rat]

And it's leading to lots of conversations about things between different House's views of things.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[batrachian]

needs a Hufflepuff icon

[contrariwise]

Personal favorite:



Loads more here, too. :)

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[lucky_guess]

It's a nice parallel for Snape and Macnair's conversations about morality/what they are prepared to do compared to the other Order members.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[sporky_rat]

!markdown

I love when I can have morality conversations because of a game! It makes me so happy.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[kiya]

Since I'm a Slytherclaw, I have a distinct thread of "Draco is right not just because knowing how to fight is knowing how to fight, but because more complete knowledge IS POWER. Especially when it's knowledge about THE MECHANISMS OF POWER."

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[kiya]

... which means I'm with ... Ron.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[sporky_rat]

Ron is being surprisingly sensible about this whole thing. I have to wonder how the rest of the ISS falls in the debate and what Terry and the Twins and Lee would think.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[kiya]

We've got Terry now!

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[adeliej]

Seconded. The approach of "I don't necessarily want to be using this in fighting, but knowing it is very useful for defence" is one I agree with.

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[aedifica]

Yay inter-House breeding! I'm either a Ravenpuff or a Huffleclaw, myself. (I change my mind from time to time which I am.)

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[kiya]

I had a conversation a few months ago that went something like:

"I am happy to be identified as a Ravenclaw in public."
"How Slytherin of you."

Re: is on draco's side here, but sees justin's view as well

[batrachian]

Another Huffleclaw here. :) (Ravenpuff sounds better in my mind, but it's hard to sort out which is more dominant.)

so, uh, yeah. :)