Confirmation on the Philosopher's Stone

[longstrider.livejournal.com]

As has been mentioned in the comments to a different thread, alt_arthur all but confirms that alt_mcgonagall is the one who has, and has hidden the Philosopher's Stone at Hogwarts. So it looks like they are fairly closely mirroring the books, both in retrieval and hiding of the stone. We have yet to see if the reason is similar or if anyone is helping her protect it. Not sure who of the staff that could be given the character of the rest. With her distrust of Lupin, Slugghorn is unlikely to be in the Order, Carrow certainly isn't, Sprout *might* but we've seen no evidence of Order sympathies there, I doubt she'd take Lockhart's help even if offered and I'm blanking on the rest it's looking very like McGonagall is very much alone.

Just thought this deserved it's own post for any discussion.

As an aside, since I'm talking about the professors, has there been any mention yet of Snape? I certainly haven't noticed it if there has been.

Comments

[muggleangel.livejournal.com]

Wow! I completely didn't notice Snape not being around. Very fishy!

Judging that Voldemort knew of the prophecy, and how they seem to be sticking to canon as much as possible, I think it still was Snape who informed Voldemort, so he's probably around somewhere.

[alt-player.livejournal.com]

Oh, you'll hear about Snape. Snape's player has indeed been cast and is already playing a different character now.

After all, you didn't hear about all the important characters either right away in canon, did you? You even had to wait through an entire book for some of the best ones. Or two. Or three. Or . . .

But never fear. He'll show up! Eventually. *smirk*

[muggleangel.livejournal.com]

...Snape, is that you? :P

[alt-player.livejournal.com]

Well, if I were Snape's player, I would say, 'Ten points from Gryffindor for your cheek.' But I won't.

I actually personally recruited Snape's player to the game, however, and was extremely glad to get her. We worked on nocturne_alley together.

[longstrider.livejournal.com]

Oh I wasn't flailing about Woe Woe! where oh where is Snape?

It was more a request of the other watchers to see if I'd missed anything. Especially for such a central character who *ought* to be in the good graces the current administration, unless he was intimately involved in whatever the change was in 1981.

I have faith in you all to tell a good story :-)

[lapin-agile.livejournal.com]

Coming back to this topic to note a bit of new information. Now we know that Poppy Pomfrey is not only an ally and a benevolent figure within the school, she is an Order member as well. () That's very encouraging.

Given this, I wonder if Madam Pince is also an Order member or merely a benign figure. I'm considering that she was the first to be assigned Hermione's service and that she seemed so open to give Hermione tasks that would allow her to self-tutor and that put sensitive materials in her hands. (The counter example, of course, is boot's placement with Carrow, so perhaps these assignments are no good indicator of allegiance.)